Issue

Currently the default backend (default.ecf) will also be used for bootstrapping. There are two problems with this approach:

1. Thus the default backend first will be read with parentKey system/elektra and later with parentKey system, it needs to store absolute paths and thus won't work with the current INI plugin
2. When system is large without mountpoints, everything is reread twice during bootstrapping.

Constraints

• be compatible to mountpoints stored in defaults.ecf
• nice migration phase
• new setups should never bother about the compatibility mode

Assumptions

• Bootstrap should be fast and not unnecessarily read large files

Considered Alternatives

• Implement a hack so that system/elektra is actually read as system. (Will not solve problem 2.)
  • Its a hack.
  • Its confusing and does not play well with persistent data with relative key names.
• Split up without compatibility mode: would need to migrate all mountpoints by exporting (with old version!) and then importing (with new version!)
  • I consider this too error prone, people might easily forget to export with the old version and then discard their mountpoints unintentional.

Decision

Split up the concepts of default (default.ecf) and bootstrap (elektra.ecf) backend. During bootstrap only elektra.ecf is read. The default backend reading default.ecf is only relevant as long as no root backend is mounted.

Algorithm:

1. try to get system/elektra using the file elektra.ecf (KDB_DB_INIT)
2. if it works, mount the init backend to system/elektra (non-fallback mode)
3. if it fails (== 0 or == -1), try default.ecf as fallback
4. if the fallback works (i.e. keys are present in system/elektra), mount the default backend to system/elektra (fallback mode)

Argument

• Solves both problems
• Is fully compatible with any existing setup
• People can decide if and how to migrate

Implications

• Fallback mode should be removed with 1.0
• added scripts/upgrade-bootstrap

Related decisions

Notes

to upgrade to new system, either:

• touch /etc/kdb/elektra.ecf (loses old mountpoints)
• or do kdb export system/elektra/mountpoints, kdb rm -r system/elektra/mountpoints, kdb import system/elektra/mountpoints